(76) Understanding company financing: Equity vs. Debt Options


The financing of a company is the process of obtaining economic resources to carry out its activities, investments, and growth. Financing sources can be primarily classified into two main groups: equity financing and debt financing. Additionally, other alternatives have gained popularity in recent years. Below are the most common options within each category.

1. Equity financing

In this type of financing, investors contribute capital in exchange for an ownership stake in the company. There is no obligation to repay the contributed money; instead, the investor expects to obtain a return through future dividends or the sale of their stake when the company’s value increases.

a) Share Capital (Founding Partners) and «Friends, Family and Fools» (FFF)

  • Description: This includes resources contributed by the entrepreneurs themselves at the beginning, as well as capital from friends, family, and close contacts. These are often the first sources of financing and are based on trust in the project and the people leading it.
  • Advantages:
    • There is no need to repay the contributed capital or pay interest, which reduces initial financial pressure.
    • It strengthens the company’s balance sheet from the outset.
    • Terms with the inner circle (FFF) are usually more flexible and less formal.
  • Disadvantages:
    • It involves a dilution of ownership and control for the founders from the very beginning.
    • The available resources are often limited and may not be sufficient for ambitious growth.
    • Mixing personal relationships with business can create conflicts of interest if the project does not evolve as expected.

b) Business Angels

  • Description: These are private investors with extensive industry knowledge and investment capacity. In addition to capital, they often contribute their experience and network of contacts (known as smart money). They invest in early stages (seed or startup) in exchange for an equity stake.
  • Advantages:
    • They provide «smart money»: they not only finance but also act as mentors and open doors to new clients or partners.
    • They show a higher risk tolerance than traditional financial institutions in a company’s initial phases.
  • Disadvantages:
    • It involves a dilution of the company’s control and ownership.
    • Company valuations at such early stages can be low, which means giving up a significant percentage for a relatively modest amount of money.
    • There is a risk that the investor may want to become overly involved in daily management, creating friction.

c) Venture Capital

  • Description: These are specialized firms that invest in startups and companies with high growth potential and a high level of risk. They participate in growth financing rounds (Series A, B, C…) with the goal of multiplying their investment and selling their stake within a 5 to 10-year horizon.
  • Advantages:
    • It allows access to large sums of capital, necessary to scale the business quickly.
    • They provide significant strategic support and help professionalize the company’s management, often taking a seat on the Board of Directors.
    • Their investment acts as a seal of quality and credibility that attracts talent and other investors.
  • Disadvantages:
    • Dilution is significant, with a considerable loss of control and ownership.
    • The negotiation process (due diligence) is long, exhaustive, and demanding.
    • They place strong pressure on the management team to achieve growth and profitability targets within defined timelines.

d) Private Equity

  • Description: Similar to Venture Capital, but focused on more mature, consolidated companies with stable cash flows. Their operations often involve buying majority stakes or the entire company (frequently through a Leveraged Buyout or LBO).
  • Advantages:
    • Injects large volumes of capital for restructuring, international expansion, or acquisitions.
    • They bring highly professional management aimed at optimizing efficiency and increasing value.
  • Disadvantages:
    • It usually involves the total or majority loss of control by the original partners.
    • Strong pressure for profitability and efficiency, which can lead to drastic restructuring decisions.
    • Their goal is divestment in the medium term, so their strategy is conditioned by maximizing the exit value.

e) Crowdequity (or Equity Crowdfunding)

  • Description: Collective financing through online platforms where multiple small investors contribute capital in exchange for an equity stake in the company.
  • Advantages:
    • It provides access to a wide and diverse network of investors.
    • The financing campaign process itself serves as a powerful marketing and business model validation tool.
    • The processes are typically agile and fully digitized.
  • Disadvantages:
    • It can be difficult to capture the attention of the mass of investors and reach the funding goal.
    • Managing a large number of minority shareholders (a very fragmented cap table) can be administratively complex.
    • There is a reputational risk if the funding goal is not met or if the company does not meet the expectations generated.

2. Debt financing

In this case, the company receives money that it commits to repay within a specified period, along with agreed-upon interest. The company does not give up ownership.

a) Bank Loans and Lines of Credit

  • Description: A bank loan is the delivery of a fixed amount of money to be repaid in installments. A line of credit is a limit of available money that the company can draw upon as needed, paying interest only on the amount used.
  • Advantages:
    • There is no dilution of ownership or loss of control over the company’s management.
    • The interest paid is a tax-deductible expense, which reduces the tax burden.
    • It allows for predictable financial planning thanks to a defined repayment schedule (in the case of a loan).
  • Disadvantages:
    • There is an obligation to repay the principal and interest, regardless of whether the company is profitable.
    • Personal guarantees from the partners or collateral on the company’s assets are often required.
    • The application and approval process can be slow, bureaucratic, and subject to a strict credit risk analysis.

b) Leasing and renting

  • Description: Leasing is a long-term rental of an asset (machinery, vehicles) with an option to purchase at the end. Renting is a pure rental, often including maintenance services and without an option to purchase.
  • Advantages:
    • Allows the use of productive assets without the need for a large initial investment.
    • The installments are considered a 100% tax-deductible expense.
    • Offers flexibility for renewing equipment that may become technologically obsolete.
  • Disadvantages:
    • The total financial cost (the sum of the installments) is usually higher than the purchase price of the asset.
    • The company does not own the asset during the life of the contract (and may never own it with renting).
    • There are financial penalties for early termination of the contract.

c) Factoring and confirming

  • Description: Factoring allows a company to receive early payment on its invoices by selling them to a financial institution. Confirming is a service through which a company manages payments to its suppliers via a bank, which offers those suppliers the option of being paid early.
  • Advantages:
    • They provide immediate liquidity to manage day-to-day cash flow, turning credit sales into cash.
    • They outsource and professionalize collections (factoring) or payments (confirming).
    • They can reduce the risk of non-payment, especially in the non-recourse factoring modality.
  • Disadvantages:
    • The financial cost is usually high, as it includes management fees and interest on the advance.
    • It can affect the company’s financial image. Some clients or suppliers may interpret it as a sign of cash flow weakness.
    • They are tools for financing working capital, not for long-term investments.

d) Crowdlending

  • Description: Collective financing through online platforms where multiple investors lend money to a company in exchange for an interest rate. The company repays the loan in installments.
  • Advantages:
    • The process is usually faster, more agile, and more flexible than traditional bank financing.
    • It allows for the diversification of funding sources, reducing dependence on a single bank.
    • Often, collateral requirements are lower than with banks.
  • Disadvantages:
    • Interest rates can be higher than those of a bank loan to compensate for the higher perceived risk by investors.
    • There is a risk of not completing the round and failing to obtain the necessary funding.
    • Although it is a growing market, it is still less regulated than the traditional banking sector.

e) Debt Issuance (Bonds, Promissory Notes)

  • Description: Large companies can issue debt securities (long-term bonds, short-term promissory notes) that are purchased by investors in capital markets (like the MARF in Spain). The company commits to repaying the principal plus interest on a maturity date.
  • Advantages:
    • Allows access to large volumes of financing, often greater than what a single bank can offer.
    • Diversifies funding sources, terms, and types of investors.
    • Enhances the company’s reputation and visibility in financial markets.
  • Disadvantages:
    • It is almost exclusively reserved for large companies with high creditworthiness and a proven credit history.
    • The issuance process is complex and costly (requires credit ratings, drafting of prospectuses, etc.).
    • It obligates the company to a high level of informational transparency with the market.

3. Other financing alternatives (Hybrid and Alternative)

a) Participating Loans

  • Description: This is an instrument halfway between equity and a loan. The interest paid has a fixed component and a variable one, linked to the company’s performance (profits, revenue, etc.). It is subordinated debt, meaning that in case of financial trouble, it ranks behind common creditors for repayment.
  • Advantages:
    • It is very flexible, as the financial cost adapts to the actual performance of the business.
    • For solvency purposes (capital reduction and liquidation), it is considered as equity, strengthening the balance sheet.
    • It improves the financial structure to be able to apply for additional bank financing.
  • Disadvantages:
    • The financial cost can become very high if the company performs excellently.
    • As it is subordinated debt, the lender assumes more risk, which can increase the fixed interest rate or entry conditions.

b) Grants and Public Subsidies

  • Description: Funds, generally non-repayable, granted by public administrations (local, regional, state, European) to promote strategic activities such as R&D, job creation, exports, or digitalization.
  • Advantages:
    • It is free financing (non-repayable) or comes with very favorable repayment conditions.
    • It does not dilute ownership or create debt on the balance sheet.
  • Disadvantages:
    • The application process is highly bureaucratic, slow, and very competitive.
    • There is great uncertainty about whether the aid will ultimately be granted.
    • It requires exhaustive justification of expenditures and strict compliance with the objectives for which it was granted.

Publicado por José Luis

un financiero, con alma de comercial; un comercial, con formación financiera

Deja un comentario